This Thursday, I will be moderating a panel at ConnecTechAsia entitled “Can Satellite and Mobile Co-Exist”. I think it is truly unique because, for the first time, we actually had satellite and mobile engineers talking to each other!
You can watch that panel during the “5G and Spectrum” session in ConnecTechAsia/SatelliteAsia on Thursday 1st October from 14:30 Singapore Time…
Session information go to: https://www.connectechasia.com/home/co-located-agenda/3/?searchInput=&events%5B0%5D=ConnecTechAsia&events%5B1%5D=SatelliteAsia
That panel and this being my 50th year in communications got me thinking. Why? Because I see our satellite industry is not cohesive. The arguments about spectrum remain between terrestrial and satellite, each major part of the communications industry at loggerheads with each other over how to share or reorganise spectrum standards, proprietary versus open, but our dear satellite industry still talks in terms of proprietary or bespoke products and services.
So, what was the trigger for my thinking?
For me, 5G has simply been the missed opportunity. The two parts of our communication industry, satellite and mobile, are so far apart when each need each other to succeed. We have truly lost the plot!
Communication is a single entity. There are no boundaries, just routes.
Whilst celebrating my 50 years a few weeks ago, a friend and fellow member of the Goonhilly Heritage Society remarked that he believed that the construction of TAT-8 in 1988 triggered the split between terrestrial and satellite. The belief is that from that point on the two industries separated and both vying to be top dog.
By the way, TAT-8 was the 8th TransATlantic communications cable laid but, more importantly, the first transatlantic fibre-optic cable, carrying 280 Mbit/s (40,000 telephone circuits) between the United Kingdom, the USA and France.
Fibre had arrived and satellite lost their main business. But by then, DTH (Direct to Home [TV]) had arrived as the new era for Satellite. Was that the start of SAT 2.0?
Commercialism took over from common-sense and the number one rule that communications needs all available network layers to connect was suddenly, broken.
Where Are We Today?
A good question. Turmoil springs to mind and I’m not sure that COVID-19 is the root cause, our satellite industry was creaking before then, COVID just speeded it up.
The dilemmas…
The arguments around spectrum remain critical to the financial survival of satellite operators both in keeping or selling frequency bands. The trouble is the arguments continue and to me there is financial gain for all here if only the terrestrial and satellite parties would work together. There are brave moves in the USA regarding C-Band that I think will work well for all in the end. Each region of the world has different priorities and so spectrum decisions must be made by balancing the practical use against the services needed.
There is some work going on to look at sharing spectrum. Tricky but this should be a joint effort.
We now have Terrestrial versus LEO versus MEO and GEO
The satellite industry seems hell bent on providing proprietary services or systems. We know that satellite needs to always look at reducing costs so if we keep thinking this way the industry will never reduce costs enough and terrestrial will continue to go its own way.
Satellite needs to implement modified existing 5G protocol standards and, probably, a specialised management layer to allow satellite transmissions to be a seamless connection for 4G/5G so routing via terrestrial or satellite is simple. Using standards for DTH, etc. has proved profitable for our industry then the same must be applied to provide connections for all mobile and associated services such IoT applications.
However, we know that ESA supports integration to 5G in some current projects. But who is picking up on this? Do these projects engage with the Mobile industry? None of this is visible or discussed openly. Or is it that the Mobile see us as too slow to respond and the subject matter is not exciting enough? There answer maybe that they can already develop these services quicker and cost effectively.
At least on September 16th the European Commission is promoting all member states to boost investment in very high-capacity broadband connectivity infrastructure, including 5G. And one important statement was made, and I quote…
“Broadband and 5G connectivity lay the foundation for the green and digital transformation of the economy, regardless if we talk about transport and energy, healthcare and education, or manufacturing and agriculture,” stated Executive Vice-President for a Europe fit for the Digital Age, Margrethe Vestager. “And we have seen the current crisis highlight the importance of access to very high-speed Internet for businesses, public services, and citizens, but also to accelerate the pace towards 5G. We must therefore work together towards fast network rollout without any further delays.”
Back to the problem…
The only thing I hear is Backhaul. Fine that is good business and should be continued as satellite is a great way to service this need. But surely the conversation needs to move on. We know about backhaul and the continued role for satellite. This just brings home that each industry needs each other to operate. But we need to push the conversation forwards and be the technology innovator.
But we do know that 5G Broadcast is available and that is something we never talk about. Yet, that is really something the satellite network can deliver, and now.
Remember, users are application based not service based!
The ‘App’ rules!
The Mobile Position?
Their stance? It is possible to coexist.
Engineers are ready to find solutions and probably can resolve. However, it is very hard to find solutions with the ongoing political battles.
Yes, they do have both mobile and satellite networks. They do use satellite backhaul. They understand that satellite has a fixed role at present to connect to those areas that would be very difficult on a terrestrial only basis. But mobile operators are also looking at HAPS (High Altitude Pseudo Satellites) solutions.
Before I move on the following facts surrounding backhaul that may interest the reader. The mobile industry only uses backhaul via satellite when it must and is not the preferred method of operation due to cost and complexity. The mobile uses about 1.5% of its total network connectivity utilising satellite backhaul. Not that impressive? We do need to understand that there is a significant difference in revenue generation between the two industries which is why, when looking at the satellite industry’s business, backhaul accounts for around 20+% of the revenue.
But for the satellite industry to always talk about supplying backhaul to the mobile vertical is so short sighted when it could have a real role in delivering 4G, 5G and more. It is like the satellite industry has all its eggs in the backhaul basket!
How many times do we hear from our industry that talk about new satellite services for mobile, but these are either very specialised or never happen!
As soon as spectrum usage and using the same bands rears its ugly head the difficulties begin for all. That is where the tension starts! And nobody seems to want to remove this obstacle and that is where we are stuck today!
The Satellite industry states it wants an open dialogue with the Mobile industry but what is said is simply not translated into real discussion. The last four rounds of WRC (World Radio Conferences) have led to the complete opposite.
The mobile industry would welcome open dialogue and believes in coexistence and they would be able to find resolutions to meet.
3GPP (3rd Generation [Mobile] Partnership Program) is working on the issue (albeit slowly) and that is positive. We know that many Telcos have interests in both mobile and satellite. But it is not up to the mobile industry to say that satellite has a role to play in 5G or not moreover, will the satellite industry develop the technology to deliver their role in 5G? Mobile is not going to develop the role, technology or integration for the satellite industry that is up to the satellite industry. In the meantime, mobile continues to develop 5G and now, 6G networks.
Note, there was a role for satellite in 3G, designed by the ITU, but it was never followed through. And there we have it, the mistake, satellite never followed through with the obvious way forward for the future of both terrestrial and satellite networks!
Will it be different this time? The onus is squarely on the satellite industry to deliver their role in 5G.
The conclusion here is, that open discussion and the necessary management and engineering collaboration is needed, and now!
Rethinking Our Role
So, how do we change the conversation within the satellite industry? Perhaps we should be thinking in term of 5G as a SAT 3.0 revolution?
My view is that we must start looking at the 5G opportunity from a new perspective.
I have attended many events and online webinars and you hear the same story about individual company’s service offering or product range.
Where does that leave the user?
Satellite is not going to work well where a User really needs a connection such as, in the Home, the Office, the Car, the Plane or the Cruise Ship.
But Satellite can easily deliver to the cell tower! Satellite can enhance cell-tower connections both nationally and globally. Remember my reference to 5G broadcast earlier, this is where Satellite can deliver a role.
Well for those that travel let us look at the typical internet offer when flying.
The device you have is not the problem.
Each airline is running its own internet show based on a proprietary service offering only applicable to that airline. That means having to login. Having to pay with a card. Then doing this all over again between flights and different airlines. Every time!
Moving on. At the end of 2019 I was at an event in London, and for the first time I thought, yes, we are finally having the right conversation. But sadly no. It was about the problem of billing! And there you have it. Everything is not seamless and simple to for the user. And there lies the inherent problem.
It was interesting that billing was sort of at the heart of the issue and that we, as an industry, must get to grips with.
We need to consider the way mobile services are run now.
We all know it is a cell structure. The mobile operator provides the deal. You pay, for example, monthly or perhaps ‘as-you-go’ and for that you have a tailored package to meet your total need. It is all setup by mobile operator you choose. To use your mobile device is simple you switch on and the system does the rest. No logging on, you tweak the package to meet new requirements and add extras at the time when you need them. And this concept is the key that is what our industry must take on board.
There are two major areas for the satellite industry to rethink…
- Service Provision, and…
- The Network Technology to support it.
Regarding Service Provision: We must get away from the proprietary thinking that follows our industry around in many areas of supply.
The service should start and stay with the mobile operator. They set the packages up for the User. Packages from pay-as-you-go to fully inclusive. In the case of special services offered they can then add personalised airline/air-minutes and/or data pack or, as another example, a cruise ship pack. And packages can be integrated as part of a fully inclusive deal or be taken up as extras, as and when the User wishes. The point is, the mobile operator sets the ball in motion, it has the processes now, it does the billing and thus make it simpler for the User. Just as people travelling for leisure or business have the packages to suit their needs right now. All the service that satellite are needed for become part of that common and well-liked way we use our mobile devices.
The mobile operator pays-back to the airline its share of the usage and probably be a part of the equipment supply chain for the aircraft, cruise ship, or other vertical…
This simplifies integration of services for an airline, takes away the pain and finally terrestrial and satellite are truly working together to supply an integrated connection for users. Seamless, simple, and managed!
The beginnings of this idea were shelved in the early 2000s such as the work done one some British Airways aircraft that proved satellite connection was both viable and extremely useful.
We had the beginnings we just need top pick-up where we left off…
This is the big move our industry must make.
To match the service provision outlined then a better Network Technology concept needs to be in place.
Consider the airline example outlines above, in fact let us concentrate on the aircraft itself. Scrap the idea of the aircraft as a particular airline’s service, simply consider it a mobile cell or several integrated cells, depending on size. Note, this simple concept can apply to anything from a building to a cruise ship.
As soon as you make everything a continuation of the mobile cell structure you have immediately met the new requirement of service provision outlined above. That’s it. The User simply turns on their cell phone or device and the rest is automated in the normal way and that User can use their device for as much as they have signed up for with their mobile service provider.
No more logging in every time you change planes, hoorah! 😊
The Technology Needed
What do we need to do to make it possible for satellite connection layers to become an integral part of the mobile network?
At least some in our industry are part of 3GPP, that’s a start.
But is it enough? I don’t think so.
To get the best out of 5G we need better protocol and signalling layers which will no doubt lead to new protocol and signalling schemes that are standardised for use to connect satellites to both the current 4G and the new 5G environment.
We need to advance how we use and integrate IP everywhere. It is the common ground we need to build from. But to allow more data to flow we need those efficient and, maybe, new modulation schemes to make that a reality.
We need to ensure our networks are all software defined to take advantage of the more complex management scenarios envisioned and to stay up to date.
We need to really improve automated management systems to manage both spectrum and network seamlessly. A “Smart” network. A possible solution to sharing spectrum, perhaps?
We also need to stop worrying about everything mobile. 4G & 5G can do that better terrestrially, for example, the connected car. The real opportunity here is for satellite networks to join the individual cells together adding the satellite communication layer in parallel to that of the normal fibre. That will allow more data to be fed to or received from those connected to that cell. The ability to offer global and direct cell-to-cell operation. Mind we will need that smart network infrastructure to do that😊
Our suppliers need to also understand that they need to bring in standardised and open application interfaces. In the Telco world we already have both operational and application maps that allow its suppliers to provide equipment to a standardised application interface. We, therefore, must move away from our “protective” approach to supplying networks and systems. This is a must for our industry suppliers to think the Telco way before the Telco world does it anyway! May be that is happening already?
We know that Flat Panel Antennas (FPA) are progressing but far too slowly to make mobile satellite for all cost effective or even possible. We need a reality check, the promises for FPA have taken too long. I think eventually the FPA will succeed but not for many years, especially if real low cost is required. We do not have make this the “be all” or “end all” moment. Move on. Think cell structure and join those cells. They are fixed points terrestrially and thus simpler to use conventional antenna technology for now. Cost effective and will achieve the global reach.
Satellite can concentrate where the real money is on making aircraft, shipping, military, IoT and other specialist mobile connections work and as the only way they will work!
And better tools using AI and machine learning at their core.
A lot to do but nothing that surprising and certainly the beginnings of this technology is available now, our industry just needs to build on it…
A comment from a good friend and colleague made me smile at this point, and I quote: “If a Satellite Operator would like to implement an AI project today it is comparable to applying autonomous driving software to a Citroen 2CV”.
Bringing People Together
Being my 50th year in communications certainly has taught me one thing. Communication is the deal.
To continue its progress and offer better services to everyone globally then the terrestrial and satellite industries need to converge their networks.
It has already been stated by Eutelsat recently that “Satellite Operators are ‘Too Small,’ industry consolidation needed to stay competitive”. Something I have thought for some time. But consolidation is not enough on its own. Joining people together should allow our industry to do more and better serve everyone in communications and help establish that global, terrestrial and satellite “Smart” network.
But I think it probably will migrate further in that mobile operators have the money to invest in a more integrated and seamless network. They are key, but not exclusively.
We are at a time where we must be more inclusive!
The first step would be for both industries to work together and get a much better understanding of their individual models work and lead to more constructive and open conversation in getting our global communications fit for purpose.
That “Smart Super-Network” Is Needed Now!
And I do mean now!
The work must start now, and it must be inclusive.
If we want to connect the planet, all 7+ Billion of us, then that must be done together, both terrestrially and using the array of layers of communications in space, from the new LEO constellations, through MEO and GEO.
The satellite layers add so much flexibility to communications, but we are just not making the point. Too busy inventing our own service packages and trying to compete for all verticals.
We need both a smart network and smart automation as that will be the only true way forward.
Software definition has advanced dramatically and so has the use of AI and machine learning techniques.
We need to bring these super subjects together and jump start a new age of network management.
Being clever with the resources we have will then allow our spectrum to be better used, dynamically managed and be able to re-use portions for numerous purposes and not simply dedicate to either Satellite or Terrestrial. That must stop!
Yes, I know, disaster recovery, our global health needs need specific areas of spectrum to be available to satellite. That equally applies to terrestrial. But there is plenty to go around. It is crazy that we “manually” allocate spectrum through laborious procedures and that 4-year rolling process of WRC! We must be more dynamic than this. 4-years to figure out and settle the latest round of debate, technology and users need our industries to do better than this.
Ridiculous! Madness! These terms spring to mind when thinking about WRC…
We just need to apply our joint brain cells together and resolve through better and automated management of spectrum, a valuable and limited resource.
I wonder how much of the spectrum given to us is used.
Would it not be better to know that answer and be able to share or reconfigure to suit the immediate needs for all?
A dynamic, smart, super-network is the only way forward. We have the knowledge to do this, we just need to adjust our thinking to allow it to happen, and soon!
PS: Final Thoughts
One thing did stand out to me writing this article. Satellite does provide that vital layer of communications providing us all with Safety, Disaster Recovery, Medicine/Health Care, Tracking (Aero, Maritime, Freight/Fleet-Trucks/Cars) and, of course, navigation through the various GPS services available. Satellite delivers this totally and is the only high reliability network for such cases. That must stay in place, at all costs!
However, to keep that in place the Satellite Industry needs to do business to allow this vital piece of the humanities puzzle to exist.
Why do I mention this, apart from its obvious importance?
A continuous part of all the webinars I have listened to over recent months have nearly all, without exception, played on this vital service that the satellite community provides globally.
And what is the problem with that?
That does not grow the business, from a harsh business point of view it simply appears to be appealing to our sympathetic nature not thinking about looking at providing a strong business model.
The point of this article? 5G is the great opportunity. We have missed out once at the 3G inception and we blather on about backhaul. We are not innovating fast enough to make 4/5G better to help connect and make mobile stronger, more affordable and for everyone!
Just one more thought. Have you noticed how I talk in terms of Mobile and Satellite being industries? It is interesting that an industry is something that has standards, processes and is automated in its operation. Something the Communications Industry is or certainly, should be. Thus, both Mobile and Satellite are really a branch of the Communications Industry. I also think the Mobile branch is better placed and meets that demand of the Communications industry. So where does that leave the Satellite branch?
Going back to the “Mobile opinion” and to leave you with this fundamental question:
When will the Satellite Industry finally step up and develop the technology to deliver their role in 5G?





